Are Values Just a Matter of Taste?
My wife’s therapist asked us to rank 58 values. The worksheet defines values as “how a person wants to act on an ongoing basis”. It then adds: “there are no such things as ‘right values’ or ‘wrong values,’ it’s a bit like your taste in pizzas.” Comparing values to food preferences is oddly trivializing. Preferring selfishness to generosity is different from preferring mushrooms to pepperoni.
I think there are right and wrong values. Consider a friend who loves to talk about themselves. They call and talk about their work, their problems, their stories. They don’t ask about you, and if you start to talk, they quickly pull out their phone. When you complain, they say, “Honestly, I’ve got enough going on in my own life. I don’t want to listen to your problems.” Is this just a matter of your friend liking mushroom pizza while you prefer pepperoni?
The idea that all values are relative is widely held. (I’m reminded of the opening pages of The Closing of the American Mind.) It’s comforting—the therapy worksheet was trying to reassure us—if there’s no right or wrong, you can’t be wrong! The uncomfortable truth is that some values are right and others are wrong, and some are more important than others. Deep down we all know this. The selfish friend is a familiar example, but entire societies valued things we regard as wrong: Spartans valued loyalty to the state above personal freedom and the submission of wives to their husbands; the Aztecs valued human sacrifice. The same is true of art: we may disagree about whether Bach is better than Taylor Swift, but we’d all agree that both are better than the six-year-old playing piano down the hall.
Perhaps the worksheet really meant “within the range of normally accepted values, there is no basis for preferring one over another.” This is a more defensible position, which I could accept with a few caveats.
I think some values are objectively better than others, but ranking them requires more context and precision than value terms provide. Value terms, like other terms, are models: simplified descriptions of reality useful for some purpose. What exactly does “justice” mean? Socrates had people try defining such terms, but they couldn’t because language is so approximate. That doesn’t make these terms useless; it means that ranking them would require context and precision that their standard definitions don’t encode.
There are situations where we do get very precise. I imagine the creators of self-driving cars are working through ethical issues with greater precision and more context than may have been used previously. After all, humans do their best in a crash event, but self-driving cars are programmed to make split-second value judgments. How should a car weigh hitting a child against hitting a larger truck, given the probable outcomes of each? What about a dog?
Medical-device development offers another concrete example, on which I can speak with some authority. When performing a safety and security risk assessment for a device, we try to make the device’s risk–benefit tradeoffs as explicit and context-specific as possible. What harms could occur, under what conditions, and how severe might they be? What risks remain after we take steps to reduce them, and are those risks justified by the expected benefits for the intended patients and use? These judgments may initially be qualitative. As the device is more widely used, real-world use refines the model.
So even if some values are right and others wrong, the words alone don’t give us enough context or precision to rank “ambition” against “fitness”. I see this as the most generous reading of the statement that no values are right or wrong.
As a final aside, examining your calendar and budget is a simpler, more concrete way to identify your values than picking your top six words. How do you spend your time and money? How much time do you spend with your family? Your friends? Going to the opera? Reading? Working out? You may discover a gap between your stated values and how you actually spend your time and money. Starting with your calendar and budget makes it easier to see that gap and bring the two into alignment.